EPF vs PPF Comparison: Which One Should You Choose
915 Views
195
When planning for long-term goals like retirement, selecting the right savings instrument is crucial. Two popular options in India are the Employee Provident Fund (EPF) and the Public Provident Fund (PPF). Both offer tax benefits and growth potential, but they serve different purposes. While a PPF account provides flexibility in contributions with tax-free interest, an EPF account mandates contributions from both the employee and employer, fostering enforced savings. Understanding the EPF vs PPF comparison helps investors choose the option that aligns with their financial goals and job status.
What is an EPF Account?
The Employee Provident Fund (EPF) is a retirement savings scheme aimed at salaried employees. Managed by the Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO), it involves monthly contributions from both the employee and employer. Each month, 12% of the employee’s salary (basic pay plus dearness allowance) is deducted and matched by the employer, forming the EPF fund.
Eligibility: EPF is compulsory for salaried employees with a monthly income of up to ₹15,000. Those earning more than this threshold have the option to voluntarily enrol in the scheme.
Interest Rate: The interest rate is revised annually and is based on the returns from government bonds and securities. For FY 2023-24, the interest rate is 8.25% p.a.
Additionally, the EPF amount accumulates over time, offering employees a significant retirement corpus. Under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, 1961, contributions to the EPF account are eligible for tax deductions. This makes the EPF a beneficial scheme for both retirement savings and EPF tax relief.
What is a PPF Account?
The Public Provident Fund (PPF) is a long-term savings scheme designed to encourage individuals, especially non-salaried people, to build a retirement corpus. It is available to all Indian citizens, including salaried individuals, self-employed, and minors (via a guardian).
Eligibility: Any Indian citizen can open a PPF account. However, a person can only hold one account.
Interest Rate: Set quarterly by the government, the interest rate for July-September 2023 was 7.1% p.a.. The PPF amount grows over time, with returns being compounded annually and tax-free.
Key Differences Between PPF and EPF
Here is a comparison table highlighting the key differences between EPF and PPF:
Particulars |
Employees Provident Fund (EPF) |
Public Provident Fund (PPF) |
Issued By |
EPFO, under the Ministry of Labour, Government of India |
Government of India through post offices and banks |
Account Type |
Mandatory for salaried employees |
Voluntary for all Indian citizens |
Purpose |
Retirement savings with employer and employee contributions |
Long-term savings for all individuals |
Interest Rate |
8.25% p.a. (FY 2023-24) |
7.1% p.a. (July-Sept 2023) |
Maturity |
On retirement |
15 years (extendable by 5 years) |
Minimum Contribution |
12% of salary (both employer and employee) |
₹500 per year |
Eligibility |
Salaried employees in firms with 20+ employees |
Open to all Indian citizens |
Withdrawal rules |
Partial withdrawals after 5 years for specific purposes |
Partial withdrawals after 7 years |
Taxation |
Tax-free interest, subject to conditions |
Fully tax-free interest and maturity |
Tenure/Lock-in Period |
Until retirement or job change |
15 years (extendable) |
Loan Facility |
Allowed for specific needs |
Loan allowed from the 3rd year onwards |
Premature withdrawal |
Under special conditions (e.g., medical, education) |
After 5 years, under limited circumstances |
Liquidity |
Lower, strict withdrawal rules |
Moderate, partial withdrawals allowed |
Risk Factor |
Low-risk, backed by government securities |
Low-risk, government-backed, guaranteed returns |
Growth Potential |
Higher due to employer contribution |
Fixed growth |
Taxation on Withdrawal |
Tax-free after 5 years of continuous service; taxable if withdrawn earlier |
Completely tax-free, regardless of tenure |
Transferability |
Transferable between employers, ensuring continuity of savings |
Non-transferable but can be maintained anywhere in India |
Contributor to Fund |
Both employer and employee contribute 12% of salary |
Sole contributor; voluntary contributions of ₹500 to ₹1.5 Lakhs annually |
Governing Act |
Employees' Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 |
Public Provident Fund Act, 1968 |
Employer Contribution |
Yes, employer contributes 12% of basic salary and dearness allowance |
No employer contribution; entirely self-funded |
Scheme offered by |
EPFO, under the Ministry of Labour and Employment, Government of India |
Post offices and designated banks, under the Government of India |
EPF vs PPF: Which One is Right for You?
When deciding between EPF and PPF, consider these factors:
Job Status
If you are a salaried employee, EPF may be a favourable option due to employer contributions. However, if you are self-employed or looking for more flexibility, PPF could be a better money investment choice.
Long-term Financial Goals
EPF is ideal for building a retirement corpus with fixed contributions. PPF is flexible, allowing smaller contributions.
Risk Tolerance
Both EPF and PPF are low-risk, but EPF offers higher growth potential due to employer contributions.
Flexibility
PPF is more flexible, allowing lower and variable contributions, while EPF involves fixed contributions tied to your salary.
Many individuals opt for both EPF and PPF to diversify their retirement portfolio, leveraging the benefits of employer contributions in EPF and the flexibility of PPF.
Types of Provident Funds
There are various types of Provident Funds aimed at promoting disciplined savings for retirement:
Employee Provident Fund (EPF)
For salaried employees, both the employee and employer contribute 12% of salary. Managed by the EPFO, it offers tax benefits and an interest rate of 8.15% p.a. for FY 2023-24.
Public Provident Fund (PPF)
Available to all citizens, PPF accounts offer tax-free returns with a maturity amount that can be withdrawn after 15 years.
General Provident Fund (GPF)
Exclusively for government employees, it allows monthly salary deductions with a guaranteed return. The interest rate is aligned with PPF (currently 7.1% p.a.).
Voluntary Provident Fund (VPF)
A Voluntary Provident Fund (VPF) allows employees to contribute beyond the standard 12% of their basic salary to their EPF account. However, these additional contributions are not matched by the employer.
Conclusion
When looking at PPF vs EPF, it’s important to note that PPF accounts offer greater flexibility with contributions, making them ideal for individuals with irregular incomes, whereas EPF accounts provide the advantage of employer contributions, making them more suitable for salaried employees. Both have different lock-in periods and tax deductions under Section 80C, making the choice dependent on personal financial goals and employment status.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if I change jobs?
When changing jobs, your EPF account can be transferred to your new employer, ensuring continuity in savings.
Which companies have a mandatory EPF?
Companies with 20 or more employees are required to offer EPF to their workers.
What is the purpose of EPF and PPF?
Both EPF and PPF are designed to help individuals build a retirement corpus, with tax benefits and compounding returns over time.
Is NPS better than PPF?
NPS (National Pension System) offers market-linked returns and could offer higher growth potential but comes with more risk compared to the guaranteed returns of PPF.
Can PPF be considered a pension plan?
PPF is not a pension plan but can be a part of retirement planning due to its long-term nature and tax-free returns.
How do EPF vs PPF interest rates compare?
For FY 2023-24, EPF offers an interest rate of 8.15% p.a., while PPF provides 7.1% p.a. for the July-September 2023 quarter. The EPF amount benefits from employer contributions, generally providing higher returns, while PPF offers tax-free interest and more flexibility.
